| By JOHN MARQUIS
AN ex-con turned pastor revealed last night how he trapped
the Nassau swindler Derek Turner - and prevented what could
have been one of the biggest global investment scams of all
time.
Barry Minkow nailed the 55-year-old New Zealand conman in
a classic FBI sting operation, posing as an investor with
$2 million to risk in Turner's get-rich-quick hedge fund.
As a result, Turner - who operated his investment racket from
his luxury home on Paradise Island - now faces seven years
in prison, having defrauded 30 investors of $16 million. He
admitted the fraud in a plea deal with the Feds to avoid a
20-year stretch, which could have led to him dying behind
bars.
Mr Minkow, himself an ex-fraudster with a seven-year jail
term behind him, said Turner finally confessed because incriminating
conversations between the pair had been wire-tapped by federal
agents.
And it quickly became clear that the flamboyant trickster
had neither the trading record nor funds to back up extravagant
claims made in his business prospectus.
"If Turner had been allowed to go on another year, he
would have been involved in a worldwide, multi-million dollar
scam," Mr Minkow told me from the US headquarters of
the anti-fraud agency he now runs alongside his church activities.
"I hope five years from now that he will realise we saved
him from himself.
A Wall Street Journal guy exposed me, and although I hated
him at the time, I came to realise it was the best thing that
ever happened."
After his arrival in the Bahamas in the year 2000, he bought
five properties, including an office on East Bay Street, in
an attempt to "look big" in front of his wealthy
neighbours on Paradise Island.
Socialising
One of his tactics was to oil his way into the company of
celebrities and high-rollers, and he was particularly pleased
with himself when he bought an Ocean Club Estates property
near baseball ace Barry Bonds.
But, according to Mr Minkow, the plausible villain was cash-starved
to the point where he was desperate to lay hands on the $2
million he (Minkow) pretended to hold as a potential investment.
"He claimed to have a $500 million fund, and to be generating
a 40 per cent return. Why, with a supposed $200 million a
year income, would he be interested in my $2 million?"
asked Mr Minkow.
"At that rate, he could double his money every two-and-a-half
years, yet he was pressing me to invest and I knew he had
a need for cash. Perpetrators of ponzi schemes always need
cash.
"What Turner was doing was taking investors' money and
buying real estate.
He needed to look big because that's the only way you can
attract investments from the genuinely wealthy.
"You can't operate a successful investment fund and run
around in a Toyota.
He knew if he could build up an empire, he could mix with
the right kind of people. Having a home near someone like
Barry Bonds was very important to him."
That is when the FBI installed the prisoner-turned-preacher
in a room at Atlantis and began a four-day sting operation
that eventually brought Turner to justice.
Meetings
Mr Minkow had two meetings with Turner - one over dinner at
the New Zealander's home, when promises of a 38 per cent return
were made in an attempt to lure the pastor into his scheme.
The dinner was ostensibly a pleasant social occasion, but
Mr Minkow was all the time wiring the "smoking gun"
evidence that was to be Turner's downfall.
"Sadly, he reminded me a lot of me," said Mr Minkow,
"he was charismatic and absolutely sure of himself. He
was one of those guys who simply protesteth too much.
"He claimed his Taiwanese wife's family had $250 million
in the fund. He wanted to create an image for himself. He
had to make sure that his image tied in with his story."
So where did Turner go wrong?
According to Mr Minkow, the rogue trader erected a wall between
his investors and independent corroboration.
"He never showed anyone trading records that would independently
back up that he made 38 per cent a year. He had no audited
financial statements. You were left with his charts, his words
and his personality.
"These investors had never seen any independent corroboration.
No-one gets these returns on a consistent basis."
Turner's portfolio was subjected to the scrutiny of an independent
markets expert who reported that it was impossible to constantly
generate the results he was claiming on a monthly basis.
Authorities
Turner also erred in not disclosing his brush with Australian
regulatory authorities, when he was barred from trading because
he didn't have a licence.
"He said in his prospectus that for seven straight years
he generated huge returns, yet for part of that time he was
shut down," said Mr Minkow.
When Turner was first arrested in New York, he denied wrongdoing
and tried to pin a defence on Mr Minkow's undercover methods.
But the wire-tapped evidence against him was so strong, so
powerful, that he eventually accepted the game was up.
Rather than face 20 years in jail, he "fessed up"
and plea-bargained a seven-year term, with formal sentencing
expected next month.
So how does Mr Minkow feel, having tricked Turner into the
indiscretions which determined his destiny?
As a pastor who sees himself as "just one bad decision
away from another prison term", Mr Minkow does not gloat.
On the contrary, he wants Turner to learn from the errors
of his ways, to accept his dishonesty and rebuild his life.
"What you must remember is that people like us never
go into business with the intention of defrauding anyone,"
he said.
"We don't think of ourselves as villains. We always take
the view that one year from now we are going to make the big
trade and that everything is going to be okay.
"We always think people will eventually get paid. We
can sleep at night because we don't think of ourselves as
crooks."
Does Turner's incarceration give him personal satisfaction?
"I have a great satisfaction that people are not going
to be defrauded anymore. I hope that Turner's property gets
liquidated and that everyone gets repaid.
"I feel I forgive the guy. I hope he turns his life over
to God. I have nothing personal against him. I have a heart
for people who make mistakes. I am a liar who was saved by
God's grace."
Change
Claiming Turner is a man with "a lot of talent",
Mr Minkow said: "I believe that people can change. I
believe that people can come back from failure. I would visit
him in prison in a minute if asked.
"I am a pastor. I have a pastor's heart. I pray that
he will pay back his victims and come back from this failure.
And I would hope he would have a lot more humility."
Reflectively, Mr Minkow added: "All he had to do was
produce the trading records. But he didn't have the trading
records or the money."
All he had, in fact, was an elaborate impression of wealth
which he used ruthlessly to swindle others, causing heartbreak
and anxiety among those foolish enough to be taken in by his
blandishments.
Now he has seven long years in which to contemplate the error
of his ways.
|